{
  "review_kind": "INITIAL_BOUNDED_PREFLIGHT",
  "reviewer": "/root/preflight_review",
  "independent": true,
  "decision": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
  "baseline": "70954e26f62fb3df25995e31b0c615762ff85a60",
  "manifest_sha256": "075724665dde40fdd00571229a2b33490634a01d39b28c97b2a64188386ee7f1",
  "manifest_entries_verified": 562,
  "manifest_mismatches": [],
  "repo_lab_source_mismatches": [],
  "authorized_runs": [],
  "runtime": "NOT_RUN",
  "family_decisions": {
    "HISTORICAL_REPLAY": "ACCEPTED",
    "STANDARD_S0_S1_S2": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
    "VERTICAL_S3_S4": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
    "FULLSCREEN_S5_S6": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
    "HIDDEN_S7": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
    "SAVED_S8": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
    "GPU_OFFLINE_CORRECTION": "ACCEPTED",
    "HISTORICAL_NATIVE_AUDIT": "ACCEPTED"
  },
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "INITIAL-P1-01",
      "severity": "P1",
      "symbols": [
        "main",
        "Session.close_client",
        "Session.cleanup"
      ],
      "evidence": "Real cleanup reproduced status PASS and scientific_cleanup PASS despite failure ValueError: client SHM release incomplete/unobserved. main retains successful measurement status when normal_remaining raises; exited invalid client is skipped by cleanup.",
      "required_repair": "Failure must prevent overall success; archived explicit closure validation must be retained and qualify scientific cleanup; actual main/normal_remaining/cleanup adversarial regression."
    }
  ],
  "tests": {
    "graphics": 15,
    "gpu": 36,
    "historical_entries": 4688,
    "historical_files": 4250,
    "native_receipt": "PASS"
  },
  "transcription": "Faithful structured summary materialized by parent from independent read-only reviewer final response; not a verbatim transcript or reviewer-authored file.",
  "gpu_limits": {
    "plane_metadata_correction": "PASS",
    "GPU_MODIFIER_AWARE_OFFLINE": "INCONCLUSIVE",
    "GPU_DCC_DESIGN_REVIEW": "NOT_PROVEN",
    "GPU_DCC_RUNTIME": "NOT_RUN",
    "read_success": "NOT_PROVEN",
    "GL_ERROR_QUEUE": "UNOBSERVED",
    "real_epoch_rejection": "effective halfpixel"
  },
  "source_bindings": {
    "graphics/run.py": "63396e8265cdbf2b89625792460b383cf9a4e8bd9c429e25d0a4f8c0736a2adf",
    "graphics/engine.py": "1336a83e521c47a1800b21185ef1dcf340d2a543bbecb4a3552879469f04294c",
    "graphics/test_recovery.py": "4862d08ff25644f4c526ef1f045e3bb49ef2efea50b4ab590cbb68b7ab5f771e",
    "audit.py": "eee5163e4aa13720fbfc18764f198ef592ded1d544dd01de49e545c33ee15966"
  }
}