{ "schema": "corec-v2-final-global-readonly-review-v1", "reviewer": "/root/tranche_final_audit", "independent": true, "decision": "PASS", "review_status": "ACCEPTED", "scope": "Final global audit of experimental CORE-C V2 source kit, documentation, scientific evidence, lifecycle and persistence boundaries", "baseline_commit": "339dda45bc81b953e2f0afadf28765149e3a1ba1", "published_source_commit": "bf00b0b0ed3e20bfb7c68d2fbbe6553594f3167a", "blocking_findings": [], "findings": [ { "id": "N1", "classification": "NON_BLOCKING", "subject": "C7 migration oracle omits native refocus", "disposition": "Retain INCONCLUSIVE; prospective correction in a future tranche only" }, { "id": "N2", "classification": "NON_BLOCKING", "subject": "C8 owner and peer do not form the comparable two-child group", "disposition": "Retain INCONCLUSIVE and fullscreen comparison NOT_EXERCISED" }, { "id": "N3", "classification": "NON_BLOCKING", "subject": "O1 root-only close rejected by the common child-first oracle", "disposition": "Retain scientific cleanup INCONCLUSIVE, six captures and O2 NOT_RUN" }, { "id": "N4", "classification": "NON_BLOCKING", "subject": "Disclosed historical system cores and incomplete early environment provenance", "disposition": "Retain explicit historical limitations; no zero-outside-LAB claim" }, { "id": "F1", "classification": "FUTURE_SCOPE", "subject": "Per-factory sidecar memory and linear lookup scalability", "disposition": "Global performance and allocator overhead NOT_MEASURED" }, { "id": "F2", "classification": "FUTURE_SCOPE", "subject": "Remaining native qualification, production policy and maintenance decisions", "disposition": "No production integration or new runtime authorization" } ], "retained_conclusions": { "global": "PARTIALLY_ADVANCED", "disposition": "PRIVATE_COREC_V2_NEEDS_TARGETED_EVIDENCE", "oom_recommendation": "C_FURTHER_NATIVE_REVIEW", "production_availability": "UNDECIDED", "STEP20C": "NEXT", "production_multi_output": "NOT_YET_SUPPORTED", "production_authorized": false }, "independent_checks": { "git_diff_check": "PASS", "python_AST": 43, "local_document_links": 348, "unique_markers": 43, "required_answers": 16, "runtime_review_artifact_hashes": 27, "protected_hashes": 8, "CORE_scene_files_bytes_modes": 85, "CORE_mosaic_files_bytes_modes": 417, "protected_production_source_delta": "EMPTY", "offline_test_token_budget_bindings": "PASS", "runs": 12, "captures": 102, "reserved_capture_caps": 148, "all_recorded_run_durations_below_150s": true }, "sha256": { "reviewed_integration_dossier": "b9eb8a0e95501f78d6d45827793ab318ba452e0bbe65ec0d8a849f674b2c1102", "source_c_review": "26aa862c741196fdbb8d7cdf5509301e49f763cdd22ffa7bcb1a4bbf09c66f90", "remaining_runtime_final_review": "3372e0ba9f7b33da4fbc041dc4eea97ccc000fb1a9cf809b189c29c90b510569", "offline_delta_review": "a164271eab56f561f1064880be2e38f7ed4f66005f7e18df4665bdcaf73fe749", "offline_test_delta": "8d4f80c9d7f5dee53f06b9538d5523525e62eda77e4fb1632491a724e2cb8df2", "runtime_summary": "941e73254330e324d3cbc0565e3c9ccc76dcb0f8a2f76fee2a4a6a2475eed705", "budget": "dfe1897e255ca5a96b7b66b0af0728acdffdf3ddf397a3fa3c6b1011b07c9db6", "pre_final_system_check": "7392ead2d8792d854240b867c84c735e4f74eb4868c95188b6b4826d51a1bd35", "closeout_receipt_audit": "3380c7067a78ed3adb797c656f94e08b28a44e31ba5d17669b0e47a7f711f373" }, "final_publication": "PENDING_PARENT_CLOSEOUT_NOT_A_REVIEW_FINDING", "source_edits": 0, "artifact_writes_by_reviewer": 0, "new_builds": 0, "new_native_runs": 0, "new_clients": 0, "new_captures": 0, "IPC_calls": 0, "new_reservations": 0, "git_mutations": 0, "committed": false, "pushed": false, "materialized_by": "Parent transcription of explicit structured reviewer response; reviewer performed no file write" }