{
  "schema": "corec-v2-graphics-independent-source-offline-review",
  "decision": "CORRECTION_REQUIRED",
  "reviewer": "independent R-runtime reviewer",
  "source_freeze_sha256": "be6666d6b2c6fd6ea73d989f53190d6a851d32d267527fe58a1eb15c889578d6",
  "source_files_verified": 28,
  "offline_tests": {
    "command": "LAB/run-env Python unittest loader of graphics-kit/offline/test_graphics_v2.py; V2.setUp redirects only temporary fixtures into LAB/review-graphics/OFFLINE_TEST_ONLY; source modules unchanged",
    "tests": 27,
    "failures": 0,
    "errors": 0,
    "log_sha256": "e9f994eccd1e04cf7263f694745c59d46347bce2e8f2d813f4d270af5d130431"
  },
  "negative_controls": {
    "file": "negative-controls.json",
    "sha256": "a34f071e8cbf1de5a9358d54d561475849cd0a7afa7370a4051b7c5a9b836944"
  },
  "blockers": [
    {
      "id": "B1",
      "severity": "HIGH / BLOCKING",
      "file": "graphics-kit/engine.py",
      "symbol": "Session.watchdog / Session.cleanup",
      "lines": [
        91,
        98,
        202,
        205
      ],
      "requirement": "Ticket section4: duree150s/run; owned-process watchdog confinement",
      "evidence": "watchdog_at_144 returns after SIGTERM only. SIGKILL is reached only from main-thread cleanup, after sequential close_client waits and other cleanup waits. No autonomous hard deadline or escalation exists.",
      "smallest_correction": "Keep watchdog active through bounded TERM grace and SIGKILL before the150s ceiling; make cleanup use the same absolute deadline and test TERM-resistant owned process/group offline."
    },
    {
      "id": "B2",
      "severity": "HIGH / BLOCKING for C7 admission",
      "file": "graphics-kit/cases.py",
      "symbol": "dynamic_campaign",
      "lines": [
        95,
        97,
        98,
        103,
        105
      ],
      "requirement": "Ticket F7: reconstructed camera clamp and old/new clips/residual pixels after resize and migration",
      "evidence": "clamp is assigned NOT_PROVEN unconditionally. Both resize captures only feed sample_surviving (B input); no residual/whole-H2 check or reconstructed clamp assertion is applied before dynamic-ownership PASS and PARTIALLY_FEASIBLE.",
      "smallest_correction": "Implement offline-reviewed clamp and per-mutation rendered-region predicates within frozen caps, or mark C7 NOT_ADMITTED pending its narrower review; do not claim complete F7 qualification."
    }
  ],
  "accepted_components": [
    "Exact28-file source freeze verified",
    "27 offline tests pass",
    "prlimit core0:0 real non-graphic child test passes with stablePID and unchanged parent limits; argv traces validated; no preexec_fn",
    "budgets/reuse/completion/token/source/pub bindings negative controls pass",
    "additional UID/duration/publication/symlink negatives pass",
    "P1,C8,O1,O2,G2,R1 NOT_ADMITTED",
    "native generation/damage/saved/buffer/GPU limitations declared honestly"
  ],
  "non_blocking": [
    "C7 post-close capture NOT_TESTED is explicit; no additional capture budget requested",
    "Synthetic transports do not prove native input, graphics or cleanup"
  ],
  "runtime": "NOT_RUN",
  "real_reservations": 0,
  "native_builds": 0,
  "sources_edited": false,
  "commit_push": false,
  "scope": "No production/live IPC/headless/capture/GPU execution"
}